Mystery Boxes & Blind Dates

Romantasy Bookstore’s mystery collection is for readers who like their stories spicy, their surprises sealed, and their next obsession picked for them. Our Mystery Boxes mix romance-forward goodies (think bookish treats, themed extras, and a “from page to pleasure” full sized toy) with curated picks that feel like opening a present you didn’t know you needed. Whether you’re in a rom-com mood, craving morally grey chaos, or ready for full-on fantasy romance, we’ll match the vibe and keep the reveal deliciously secret.
Want the ultimate meet-cute with your next read? Our Blind Date with a Book wraps up a hand-selected title with just enough hints to tempt you—tropes, tone, and heat level—without spoiling the magic. It’s perfect for getting out of a reading slump, trying something new, or gifting to your favorite romance reader (including you). Each book is beautifully wrapped (and ready for gift giving!) with 5-7 bookish extras including stickers, bookmarks, pens, TBR lists or more!
And for customers who love a little extra spice with their stories, we also offer curated toys and pleasure picks designed to pair beautifully with your reading life—playful, body-positive, and always judgment-free. Browse in-store and let us help you build the perfect night in: one part plot, one part passion, all part fun.