Romantasy Bookstore

[PRE ORDER] The One Where They Fall in Love by Cristina Wolf

$18.99 USD

Sale Sold out

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Preorder bonus: signed bookplate, bookmark, and stickers (included with preorder)

A cozy, contemporary slow-burn that feels like your favorite comfort show: a romance editor who believes in happily-ever-afters for everyone but herself, and a routine-loving hero whose life gets flipped by one very lovable, very loud dog. The One Where They Fall in Love is sweet, funny, and full of those small moments that quietly turn into everything.

The vibe

Elle Thompson is a romance editor and lifelong romantic—thrilled her best friend is getting married (truly)… even if a tiny part of her is wondering when it’ll finally be her turn. Oliver Cole is all structure and predictability, until moving back to New York comes with an unexpected complication: Thor, the dog his sister adopted before relocating to Italy.

Thor’s late-night howling makes enemies out of neighbors fast—especially Elle, who has plenty to say about it. But when sleepless nights force a compromise, Elle agrees to watch Thor while Oliver works. What starts as a practical arrangement turns into lingering conversations, unexpected laughter, and a connection neither of them planned.

Tropes & tags

Neighbors-to-lovers
Dog dad / pet-sitting proximity
Slow burn
Grumpy/quiet hero x sunny outspoken heroine
“I don’t believe it’s my turn” heroine
Cozy NYC romance
HEA vibes

Perfect for readers of:

Low-angst, high-comfort romance
Forced proximity that feels organic
Banter + soft emotional payoff
Stories where love shows up while you’re busy not looking for it

Important preorder note: This Deluxe Edition is available only while supplies last. If it becomes unavailable, we’ll contact you before shipping with the option to switch to the standard print edition or cancel for a refund.

View full details