The Magic We Made: A Novel (Witches of West Harbor, 2) by Meg Cabot

A charming, witchy standalone romance with a mystery at its core—where a logic-first therapist keeps running into supernatural problems… and an annoyingly attractive neighbor who might be the most magical of them all. The Magic We Made blends small-town humor, slow-burn sparks, and a “prove magic is real” romance as two unlikely partners hunt for missing girls in a town drowning in witch tourism.

Francesca “Frankie” Giovanni is a trained therapist who believes there’s a scientific explanation for everything. Unfortunately, she lives in West Harbor, Connecticut, a town that’s recently blown up with “witch tourism.” Suddenly, psychics and witches are everywhere offering services—and Frankie can tolerate it… until aspiring teenage witches start disappearing and strange things begin happening at the lake house next door. Frankie suspects not everyone in town has good intentions—especially her new neighbor, Ash Merit.

Ash makes a living finding lost things—and people—and he’d love to help his clients and get to know the stunning (and newly single) Dr. Giovanni. But between troublesome young witches and Ash’s often faulty psychic “superpower,” everything goes sideways. Frankie’s refusal to believe in magic doesn’t help… especially when the chemistry between them is so intense it literally sets flames off whenever they kiss.

To get answers—and keep more girls from vanishing—Frankie and Ash will have to work together to uncover what’s really happening in West Harbor… and face a truth that could change what they believe about themselves, their town, and the magic of love.